Pet-friendly hotels in Fire Island

Popular filters:

Compare cheap pet-friendly Fire Island hotels and apartments all in one place

Look out for Fire Island hotels with free cancellation or puurrfect ratings

Discover last-minute deals for dog-friendly hotels in Fire Island

Tried and trusted Fire Island hotel providers

See all pet-friendly hotels and apartments in Fire Island

Explore Map
Prices may change – just add your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveler searches and partner prices.
All taxes and fees included
View more hotels

Other travelers love these pet-friendly hotels in Fire Island

The best pet-friendly hotels in Fire Island, as rated by others. These spots were rated well for cleanliness, customer service, and location.
Explore top-rated hotels

Fast facts

Sleep easy, armed with the stuff that’s good to know before you go.
Rated best by travelersGrove Hotel
Cheapest hotel found3.742.122 ₫, Grove Hotel
Cheapest month to stay in Fire Island May
Most expensive monthMay

Finding cheap hotels in Fire Island: FAQs

Other travelers rated Grove Hotel as the best dog-friendly hotel in Fire Island.
Yes, other travelers rated Grove Hotel as the best cat-friendly hotel in Fire Island.
The cheapest pet-friendly hotel in Fire Island is Grove Hotel.
According to our pricing calendar data, Fire Island hotels are cheapest in May.
Yes, check out Grove Hotel.
Some pet-friendly hotels charge an extra fee for having your pet stay with you. This could be a flat fee per stay, or a nightly fee. It could also come in the form of a cleaning fee.

Some hotels may offer the first pet for free, and charge for any additional pets.

It’s always a good idea to check the hotel’s pet policy to avoid any surprises.